Chris Wickham: A review of Alex Callinicos, Making History: Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory. This is an important book [Leiden: Brill, ]. Making History: Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory. By Alex Callinicos. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, p. $ – Volume 84 Issue. Making History is about the question – central to social theory – of and a wide range of historical writing, Alex Callinicos seeks to avoid two.
|Published (Last):||20 July 2004|
|PDF File Size:||12.66 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.80 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Tolga Ulusoy rated it really liked it May 27, Kate Perkins rated it it was amazing Feb 17, Thompson here—the most serious proponent, at least among historians, of the contrary position. Here, classes do not require consciousness to exist, although collectivities do. Benjamin and Sartre 5.
Making History: Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory by Alex Callinicos
In this chapter he deals with even more. Sign in via your Institution Sign in. A DefenceOxford,to arrive at a Marxist analysis through a version of first principles, constructing a Marxist position anew from the philosophy, political theory, economics and sociology of in most cases non-Marxists.
Thanks for telling us about the problem. Don’t already have an Oxford Academic account?
The Utilitarian theory of action 3. Email alerts New issue alert.
Warren Evans rated it it was amazing Jul 11, To push the argument on here, he neatly develops an insight of Giddens p. Callinicos points out that that the former are not self-conscious actors, czllinicos come to the forefront through a process of “molecular” change and frequently a “compromise” with the old order.
Martin Empson rated it really liked it Apr 09, Alex rated it really liked it Apr 25, There concepts of agency 1. The rationality of revolution 5.
Making History: Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory
Callinicos has written an extended introduction to this new edition that reviews developments since Making History was first published in Here Callinicos is on more familiar ground, but he sets the problems out with his customary rigour and verve. One of the core parts to this section, is the debate on “human nature”. Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory. Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory. Bart rated it liked it Dec 04, JRA rated it really liked it Nov 17, Mark Poster; Alex Callinicos.
Trivia About Making History: Callinicos is hostile to that tradition, and has written against it elsewhere, but it would need more attention than he gives it here and did already in How the mighty have fallen.
It deals with debates and polemics within the academic world of social theory that most casual readers will not be aware of.
A Cohen, but also the writings of revolutionary socialists like Chris Harman. At the outset, I should say that this is a challenging book.
Historical Materialism Book SeriesVolume: This is the other chapter I particularly liked, and, as noted earlier, anyone could start here. Chapter 2 argues that structural analysisand explanation are both possible andnecessary, against rational-choice Marxism, which is not only individualist but essentially undynamic especially pp.
As a historian, I am of course most interested in how this works on the ground, empirically, in the past. One therefore needs to have an theory of agency, but such a theory has to situate agents inside social structures, above all inside production relations, in order for their actions to make sense and to be empowered.
Making history : agency, structure, and change in social theory / Alex Callinicos – Details – Trove
I might push him on the problems with commodity fetishism p. Michael Chornesky rated it it was ok Jun 22, Chapter 4 comes back to consciousness, but it does so in a much amking accessible form. Marxism and the proletariat 5. That work was already mostly in the public domain inand its absence here is a flaw.